Though it’s a sequel, Return to Boone’s Hollow by Kim Vogel Sawyer is a masterpiece all its own. Threads of hope weave through the novel, and though it’s a bit slow-going, this will definitely stay on my shelf.

Ratings

Story: 3.5 out of 5

Worldview: 5 out of 5

Review

The first book (The Librarian of Boone’s Hollow) introduced Bettina Webber as a complex character. Instead of being a shallow rival for one character’s affections, Bettina was shown to be a girl desperate for love and affection—something her alcoholic father never demonstrated. This sequel explored Bettina’s growth over four years and her turmoil at the threat of her Pap returning to Boone’s Hollow, a small town in the Black Mountains. I had to say, I was pleased that this novel felt like a natural extension of book one, not like it was forced.

Considering the plot, I think this book had great elements of tension. Between the threat of Bettina’s father, homelessness, and World War II, I found myself racing to the end. This novel was very slow in parts, however, with many characters having the same conversations over and over again. I think that’s why the ending felt so sudden, even though it was definitely the right fit. I almost expected the setup for a third book, but an epilogue closed that door. 🙁

The characters consistently sought God for every problem, which is a great example. I know I am still learning to seek God for direction, and sometimes that direction comes by waiting and trusting God’s timing. It was a bit of a letdown that the waiting in the book was more slow than engaging, but it’s an accurate reflection of life, I think.

In any case, this was a good read. I love Sawyer’s books, and I definitely recommend checking them out for their strong messages of hope, redemption, and salvation!